RFC 847 UNKNOWN META · SURVEYS

Summary of Smallberg surveys

A summary of weekly Telnet, FTP, and SMTP server surveys from 1982 and 1983.

On rfc-editor.org ↗
PUBLISHED
February 1983
AUTHORS
A. Westine, D. Smallberg, J. Postel
STREAM
Legacy
BUILDS ON
RFC 846 — Who talks TCP? - survey of 22 February 1983
SURVEY PERIOD
December 1982 to February 1983
SPECIAL-PURPOSE HOSTS (ESTIMATE)
37 hosts, or 11 percent
HIGHEST REASONABLE PERCENTAGE STATED
89 percent
HOSTS IN RFC 846 SURVEY
325
DOI
10.17487/RFC0847

RFC text

Original text · RFC Editor View on rfc-editor.org ↗
Network Working Group                              A. Westine
Request for Comments:  847                         D. Smallberg
                                                   J. Postel
                                                   February, 1983


                SUMMARY OF SMALLBERG SURVEYS

This is a summary of the surveys of Telnet, FTP and Mail (SMTP)
servers conducted by David Smallberg in December 1982 and January
and February 1983 as reported in RFC 832-843, 845-846.  This memo
extracts the number of hosts that accepted the connection to
their server for each of Telnet, FTP, and SMTP, and compares it
to the total host in the Internet (not counting TACs or ECHOS).

One would not expect the percentage to reach 100, since some
hosts will be down when the surveys are run, but many hosts are
for special purposes and don't offer these services.  We estimate
that 37 hosts or 11 percent are in this catagory and the highest
percentage one could reasonably expect is 89.

                                TELNET

      RFC        DATE        ACCEPT        TOTAL        PERCENT
      ---        ----        ------        -----        -------
      832      7 Dec 82        83           315            26
      833     14 Dec 82       103           314            33
      834     22 Dec 82       102           314            32
      835     28 Dec 82        95           314            30
      836      4 Jan 83       151           315            48
      837     11 Jan 83       171           323            53
      838     18 Jan 83       172           323            53
      839     25 Jan 83       182           323            56
      842      1 Feb 83       183           382            48
      843      8 Feb 83       187           329            57
      845     15 Feb 83       176           329            53
      846     22 Feb 83       190           325            56

                                FTP

      RFC        DATE        ACCEPT        TOTAL        PERCENT
      ---        ----        ------        -----        -------
      832      7 Dec 82        70           315            26
      833     14 Dec 82        90           314            29
      834     22 Dec 82        80           314            25
      835     28 Dec 82        80           314            25
      836      4 Jan 83       132           315            42
      837     11 Jan 83       153           323            47
      838     18 Jan 83       159           323            49
      839     25 Jan 83       165           323            51
      842      1 Feb 83       170           328            52
      843      8 Feb 83       174           389            45
      845     15 Feb 82       169           329            51
      846     22 Feb 83       181           325            56

                                SMTP

      RFC        DATE        ACCEPT        TOTAL        PERCENT
      ---        ----        ------        -----        -------
      832      7 Dec 82        63           315            20
      833     14 Dec 82        82           314            26
      834     22 Dec 82        82           314            26
      835     28 Dec 82        72           314            23
      836      4 Jan 83       124           315            39
      837     11 Jan 83       145           323            45
      838     18 Jan 83       154           323            48
      839     25 Jan 83       159           323            49
      842      1 Feb 83       169           328            52
      843      8 Feb 83       170           329            52
      845     15 Feb 83       169           329            51
      846     22 Feb 83       178           325            55

ISO Plain Language

On this page
PROBLEMResults from Smallberg's weekly checks of Telnet, FTP, and SMTP servers appeared in separate RFCs.
MECHANISMRFC 847 compiles the number of hosts accepting connections and the total hosts surveyed for each service and date.
WHAT IT SHOWSThe summary covers surveys from December 1982 through February 1983 and explains why 100 percent availability was not expected.

§1What the Surveys Measured

The memo summarizes surveys David Smallberg conducted in December 1982 and January and February 1983. The individual reports are RFCs 832-843 and 845-846.

For each survey, the tables list how many hosts accepted a connection to a Telnet, FTP, or SMTP server and the total number of hosts counted, excluding TACs and ECHOs.

The surveys tried connecting to Telnet, FTP, and SMTP servers at Internet hosts. This memo brings the counts from the separate reports together.

§1Why the Rate Could Be Below 100 Percent

The memo says the percentage would not be expected to reach 100 because some hosts could be down during a survey and many hosts did not offer these services.

It estimates that 37 hosts, or 11 percent, were for special purposes and did not offer the surveyed services. On that basis, it states that 89 percent was the highest percentage one could reasonably expect.

Some hosts might be unavailable during a survey, and some were not meant to run these services. The memo uses those limits to explain why it did not expect every host to respond.

§1The Survey Tables

There is a table for each service. Each row reports the RFC number, date, hosts accepting a connection, total hosts, and percentage.

For the final listed survey, RFC 846 dated February 22, 1983, the Telnet table shows 190 of 325 hosts, the FTP table shows 181 of 325, and the SMTP table shows 178 of 325.

Each service has its own table, with one row per survey date. The final rows show the number of hosts that accepted a connection and the survey total.